Completely objective, unbiased, and neutral ranking – meaning, my own subjective preferences. Some games that I did play, but were unremarkable to me, are not in this list. No console games.
S++ Disco Elysium
S++ The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
S++ Alien: Isolation
S++ Divinity: Original Sin 2
S++ The Wolf Among Us
S+ Batman: The Enemy Within - The Telltale Series
S+ Henchman Story
S+ Pillars of Eternity II: Deadfire
S+ Batman Arkham Knight
S Batman - The Telltale Series
S Pathfinder: Kingmaker
S Pillars of Eternity
S A Short Hike
S Suzerain
S Sorcery! Parts 1 & 2
A++ Shadowrun: Dragonfall
A++ Night in the Woods
A++ Metro 2033
A++ Batman Arkham City
A++ Wolfenstein: The New Order
A+ AI: The Somnium Files
A+ Dragon Age: Origins
A+ Deus Ex - Human Evolution
A+ XCOM 2
A+ Sorcery! Part 3
A+ HITMAN
A+ Shadowrun Hong Kong
A+ Thief of Thieves: Season One
A Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag
A Shadowrun Returns
A SWAT 4
A Fallout: New Vegas
A BioShock Infinite
A XCOM: Enemy Unknown
A Pathway
A Lacuna
A The Banner Saga Trilogy
A The Life and Suffering of Sir Brante
A- Risen 2 - Dark Waters
A- Dragon's Dogma: Dark Arisen
A- Dark Souls Prepare to Die Edition
A- Wildermyth
A- Song of Farca
A- Grand Theft Auto V
A- Gamedec
A- DnD Adventure: Wizard's Choice
A- Sorcery! Part 4
A- The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings
A- Faster Than Light
A- Roadwarden
A- Terraria
B+ The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
B+ Dragon Age: Inquisition
B L.A. Noire
B Firewatch
B Ash of Gods: Redemption
B The Occupation
B Do Not Feed the Monkeys
B Frostpunk
B- Tyranny
B- Venetica
B- The Incredible Adventures of Van Helsing
B- The Complex
B- Life is Strange
B- Sid Meier's Civilization VI
B- Orwell
C+ Alpha Protocol
C+ Spellforce 3
C+ ArmA 3
C+ Euro Truck Simulator 2
C+ Citizen Sleeper
C Orwell: Ignorance is Strength
C Shadow Watch
C Agent A: A puzzle in disguise
C Fallout 4
C The Sims 4
C Beautiful Desolation
C- Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas
C- Grand Theft Auto: Vice City
C- Encased
C- Deponia The Complete Journey
C- 911 Operator
C- Slay the Spire
C- Phantom Doctrine
C- Technomancer
C- Agatha Christie - The ABC Murders
D+ Among Us
D+ Assetto Corsa
D+ A New Beginnig
D Stardew Valley
D Cities: Skylines
D Grand Theft Auto III
D- Field Hospital: Dr. Taylor's Story
D- Risen 3 - Titan Lords
D- Hand of Fate 2
F The Witcher
F XCOM: Chimera Squad
F Watch Dogs
F Beat Cop
F Anomaly Warzone Earth
F Beholder
F Tacoma
F Death Coming
F The Low Road
F We. The Revolution
F Cultist Simulator
FF My Time at Portia
FF Democracy 4
FF Watch Dogs 2
DISCLAIMER: Any and all intellectual property referenced, included, or utilized in this site that is not owned by the author of the site is used strictly for commentary, criticism, and educational purposes under the doctrine of fair use. No copyright infringement is intended. Copyright notices should be sent to the electronic mail at the top of this page.